Yet, the ethical dilemma of CL is revealed by the perspective of corresponding stakeholders in the light of the universalism theory (Meiklejohn, 1998) [12], providing rationale favouring CL in contrast (Hindman and Smith, 1999 [13]; Radfar et al., 2018 [11] ). Most importantly, CL is commonly tolerated in economically weak countries due to poverty conditions or cultural traditions (Kreikebaum, 2006) [30]. The 37 percent increase was over the previous year. [44] Posner, R.A. (1979). 1:10. Global Estimates of Child Labour: RESULTS AND TRENDS, 2012-2016. The major difficulty with Utilitarianism is that it is unable to deal with rights and justice. from: Bioethics; Principles, Issues, and Cases (2nd ed. 87. Amnesty International Report 2017/2018 - The State of the Worlds Human Rights. Only a few of these Dickensian pro-child-labor bills got enacted, but some did. Notwithstanding, CL provides impoverished families a vital source of income (Shumetie and Mamo, 2019) [50]. Subcontractors win contracts with low bids and are left to figure out how to cover costs; the Fortune 500 company that hires them really doesnt want to hear about it. Despite the suffering inflicted on many children by labour, some voices favour CL by referring their moral justification to the impoverished conditions from which it originates (Lund-Thomsen, 2008 [16]; Radfar et al., 2018 [11] ). Kant-Studien, 67(14). She also said minors who want to work deserve the same level of choice as those who want to participate in other after-school activities. 3, 1-11. "At a time when they were saying there are labor shortages, they were finding kids that would do the work," Maki says of the recent Packers Sanitation case. (2010). But once theyre assigned to a family, HHS does a poor job keeping track. Ethical Consumer. [online]. This was a radical view, in an era in which only white, property-owning males were really thought of as being entitled to a full range of rights. Table 1 allows a preliminary overview of both concepts. Meaning, from when on, are children able to develop reasons and make decisions autonomously from their parents (Yovel, 1998) [34] ? PSSI is not a target of that investigation and has not been accused of wrongdoing by DHS. A differing definition of child labour and customs, which generally regard the employment of children as an essential step in childhood, would not be compatible with the definition of deontology given in this paper. Available at: https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/AFR6273952017ENGLISH.PDF. Published in: Open Access Library Journal (OALJ) The penalties for violating these laws are smallfor employing child labor, you pay all of. [11] Chamarbagwala, R. (2008). It strives to achieve the greatest good for the greatest number while creating the least amount of harm or preventing the greatest amount of suffering. Child Labor and Responsible Consumers: From Boycotts to Social Labels, Illustrated by the Indian Hand-Knotted Carpet Industry. Copyright 2023 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc. Business ethics: ethical decision making and cases. The surge in child labor reverses what had been, for most of the past 20 years, asignificant declinein the number of minors employed in violation of the FLSA. reflections on the history of an idea. If the youngster gets hurt due to his own negligence (whatever that means at 14), the meatpacker will be indemnified against civil liability. Consequentialism. WebChild Labour: An Ethical Assesment This work is based on the application of two ethical theories deontology and , utilitarianism theory, to evaluate CL from an ethics perspective. The Business Case for Corporate Social Responsibility: A Review of Concepts, Research and Practice. "There's no safe part of a loading dock," Maki says. Secondly, all individuals affected should not be treated as mere means to another end, but rather as an end in itself, i.e. MNEs have certain responsibilities towards those who may be affected by its activities (Freeman, 1984) [40], such as employees, shareholders and customers (Chen and Roberts, 2010 [41], Siegfried 2015a [42] ). WebUtilitarianism: An Introduction 1 Some things appear to be straightforwardly good for people. By linking utilitarianism with normative stakeholder theory, relevant stakeholder groups are being identified in order to examine their influence on and role in the occurrence of child labour allowing for a practical reference. April 2013, Vol. Over the past half-century, the economy has quietly reorganized itself to separate large, respectable corporations from low-wage worker bees. The Ritsumeikan Economic Review 65(4):193205. [22] Gray, K. and Schein, C. (2012). Reprinted. Originality/Value: The examination of child labour from the perspective of deontology and utilitarianism in conjunction with normative stakeholder theory constitutes a novelty in the ethics literature. The unemployment rate, which had been falling since 2010,droppedin 2015 to 5 percent, which was then considered full employment. 0:01. They're often harvesting fruits and vegetables. [17] Donaldson, T. and Preston, L.E. Cognition, 107(3), pp.11441154. (2010). Add your e-mail address to receive free newsletters from SCIRP. Purpose: Grounded in the theoretical concepts of utilitarianism and deontology, this paper aims to evaluate the issue of child labour from an ethics perspective. (Edited by R. Companies Should Maximize Shareholder Wel-fare Not Market Value. [45] Potter, C. and Lupilya, A.C. (2016). A treatise of human nature. Additionally, employers have little issues with children workforce as they respect adult authority and have almost no voice to protest against their exploitation, inter alia, as not being unionised (Manda et al. In business contexts, utilitarianism implies an obligation for businesses to do what they can to act in a way that maximizes happiness and minimizes suffering. Besides, children are abused as means of cheap labour for the ends of low-cost production, which is likewise contrary to Kants categorical imperative. Here, individuals are law-givers instead of followers of the universal law as indicated in the first formula (Reath, 1989) [33]. [70] Wilk, V.A. The more common, and more invisible, problem is that through subcontracting and franchising, large corporations have made the enforcement of labor protections for frontline, low-wage workers other peoples problem. All peopleall happiness and all miserycount equally, in the eyes of utilitarians. (1993). Surely youve heard of Frito-Lay, which makes Cheetos, and General Mills, which makes Lucky Charms and Nature Valley granola bars. (2014). Children were expected to help the family in the traditional economy, but usually they had been assigned tasks that were commensurate with their age. [64] UNICEF (2014). WebChild labour is generally defined as employment of children on a sustained and regular basis. Zeitschrift fr philosophische Forschung, 31(3), pp.354384. Youve never heard of Hearthside? Or franchisees agree to terms so outrageously advantageous to the franchising name-brand company that they cant really expect to clear a profit without cutting some corners. Suggested Citation, Mrfelder Landstrae 55Frankfurt am Main, 60598Germany+4915779068623 (Phone), Economic Perspectives on Employment & Labor Law eJournal, Subscribe to this fee journal for more curated articles on this topic, Labor: Public Policy & Regulation eJournal, Subscribe to this free journal for more curated articles on this topic, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content. (After publication of the, it would require that going forward.) Un-ternehmensethik und globale Mrkte. The findings may serve companies in particular as a basis for decision-making in the development of their value chains. 3. The problem of child labor can be addressed using these moral perspectives. Table 1. [62] UN (2019). Child labor negatively affects the education and health of children who engage in it, experts say. Drawing on interviews with child welfare caseworkers, Dreier says about two-thirds of these children end up working full-time. The World Bank Economic Review, 17(2), pp.147173. 8, No. This article summarizes some features of the Radda Barnen (Swedish Save the Children) study `Children's Perspectives on their Working Lives'. However, concepts such as dignity, freedom, wellbeing and autonomy are central to both (Van Staveren, 2007) [24]. (2015). In 41 of 43 cases, working 10 hour days results in earning more than $1 per day, and in more than half the earnings are greater than $2 per day. This of course includes slavery, prostitution, debt bondage and pornography or any other sectors or works that are Some 835 companies were founded to be illegally employing minors last year, the Labor Department said, and more than 600 child labor investigations remain ongoing. [online]. "All of us together as a society and an economy have to come together and make sure that we are protecting our kids. Nobody knows exactly why the numbers started to climb in 2015, but probably it was because the labor market was getting tight. These wages are obviously quite low compared to those in the U.S., but a high percentage of people in these countries earn less than $1 or $2 per day. Beyond Utilitarianism and Deontology: Ethics in Eco-nomics. In most cases, however, child labour assumes New York: Oxford University Press. they must not be threatened in their freedom and dignity (The Humanity Formula) (Sullivan, 1997) [29]. Low level equilibrium trap, unem-ployment, efficiency of education system, child labour and human capital for-mation. Additionally, CL often times seems to be the best alternative under given circumstances. Child labour may be measured as hazardous WebThe utilitarian perspective is perhaps best understood when examined in contrast to rights-based perspectives. It is parent based," Looman says. "That's not high enough to be a deterrent for major profitable companies," the Labor Department said in a news release. "We walk a lot. (1985). A representative for Hearthside told Dreier that it did not require the staffing agency to verify its workers ages. Workers were getting hard to find. But national child labor laws prevent children younger than 16 from working more than three hours or after 7 p.m. on school nights, with the exception of farms. ASM cannot simply be shut down, however. divergent distribution and perception of CL globally. story, the role of fall guy is assumed largely by Hearthside Food Solutions. Correspondingly, Figure 1 encapsulates a general outline of global CL facts. That's hard. Tersely said, the remainder of this essay is devoted to assessing the ethics of CL by, inter alia, identifying relevant stakeholders and the implications of CL on them. Cross-Cultural Ethics and the Child Labor Problem. If they are voluntarily willing to work for the benefit of the family, this would be ethically acceptable according to Kant (Kreikebaum, 2006) [30]. It's important to hold employers accountable, "but this is also an issue that is community based. [13] Cheng, B., Ioannou, I. and Serafeim, G. (2014). [58] Sprinkle, G. and Maines, L., (2010). In June, New Hampshire Governor Chris Sununu signed into lawa billthat allows 14-year-old busboys to clear tables where liquor is served and expands from 30 to 35 the number of hours 16- and 17-year-olds may work during the school year. D Utilitarianism has been called a (n): a. commonsensical approach to ethics. Table 2. While child labor violations can affect minors of all backgrounds, "a lot of the kids we see working in exploitative situations tend to be from immigrant families" and Latino, Maki said. More than 3,800 children were found to be working at U.S. companies last year in violation of federal law, the Labor Department said Monday in announcing a crackdown on child labor. David Weil, who was Labor Department wage and hour administrator under President Barack Obama and failed to win Senate confirmation to return to that job under President Joe Bidena verycostly defeatdiagnosed this phenomenon in his indispensable 2013 bookThe Fissured Workplace. WebAccording to utilitarianism, child labor is a morally wrong action/concept, because it only brings negative consequences to the masses/objects/victims i.e. U.S. officials said the Labor Department had seen a nearly 70% increase in child labor violations since 2018, including in hazardous occupations. The Global Sourcing and Codes of Conduct Debate: Five Myths and Five Recommendations. The kind of labour that this essay focuses on is regarded as work that deprives children of their childhood, their potential and their dignity, and that is harmful to physical and mental development (ILO, 2004, p. 16) [14], which also eliminates their opportunities for proper education (Amnesty International, 2017) [15]. TIME TO RECHARGE: CORPORATE ACTION AND INACTION TO TACKLE ABUSES IN THE COBALT SUPPLY CHAIN. Utilitarianism, Economics, and Legal Theory. The ILO indicates that child labour is a global phenomenon, yet primarily occurs in the agricultural sector of economically weak regions in global terms. (1989). The Labor Departments wage and hour division recorded a37 percent increasein 2022 in the number of minors employed in violation of the Fair Labor Standards Act, whichoutlawedmost child labor way back in 1938 and imposed strict limits on the rest. A more detailed outline of both ethical. As CL being widely prohibited and morally condemned in Western economies (Pierik, 2007) [9], such violations are occurring almost invariably at the lower end of VCs in developing countries (ILO, 2017a) [10]. Its no longer just a Third World practice, or a bad memory fromHow the Other Half Lives. WebAbstract. Child Labour and UNICEF in Action: Children at the Centre. (First published in 1863). By linking utilitarianism with normative stakeholder theory, relevant stakeholder groups are being identified in order to examine their influence on and role in the occurrence of child labour allowing for a practical reference. Legislating the Moral Law. Somebodys got to be the fall guy, and its not such a bad fate. Heres What Happens When Two Crew Members Are Operating 141 Freight Cars. The Journal Review Foundation of the Americas, The Concise Encyclopedia of Business Ethics, Students Guide to Writing Critical Essays in Business Ethics. What matters is that General Mills gets off the hook by reassuring the, that it recognizes the seriousness of this situation and will get to the bottom of it. As protective mechanism, human rights equally concern all age groups, including children, who have the same basic human rights as adults. Working 10 hours every day, a 14 year old child worker from Foshan dies from exhaustion. California Management Review, 47(4), pp.1945. Consequentialism, as an ethical theory, is concerned only with the consequences of an action. Available at: https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/AFR6231832016ENGLISH.PDF. Nonetheless, not every customer is profit, but rather moral-driven or responsible. Almost every second child is aged 5 - 11. [42] Morris, R.C. Three former employees at the staffing agency, Forge Industrial Staffing, told Dreier that they shared suspicions about the age of some workers with Hearthside. See Annex A for additional comments of a rights perspective on CL. expert interviews in order to obtain expert opinions on this topic would certainly be insightful and would provide future researchers with new avenues of research. Two Minds Vs. Two Philosophies: Mind Percep-tion Defines Morality and Dissolves the Debate Between Deontology and Utilitar-ianism. [15] CorpAbuse (2020). Webultimate positive outcome that arises when a family that may not be able to naturally have a child but is able to hire a surrogate far outweighs the negatives that Anderson points out of forming a market of women. So, due to the strict distinction between good and bad there is no room for flexible intermediate decisions, which is, yet, often required in todays business environment (Scheffler, 1994) [35]. The Biden administration on Monday announced a wide crackdown on the labor exploitation of migrant children around the United States, As children are considered to have unique needs and particular vulnerability (UNICEF, 2014) [67], additional rights apply to them as outlined in the Table A1 below. Child labour not only prevents children from acquiring the skills and education they need for a better future, it also perpetuates poverty and affects national economies through losses in competitiveness, productivity and potential income. Abuses in the COBALT SUPPLY CHAIN numbers started to climb in 2015, probably!, Figure 1 encapsulates a General outline of global CL facts Minds Vs. Two Philosophies: Mind Percep-tion Defines and... Hazardous occupations role of fall guy is assumed largely by Hearthside Food Solutions TRENDS... ( 2012 ) also said minors who want to work deserve the same basic human.... Review Foundation of the Worlds human rights as adults to the masses/objects/victims i.e and Mamo, 2019 [! Defined as employment of children on a sustained and regular basis hazardous occupations Introduction 1 things... Makes Cheetos, and cases ( 2nd ed participate in other after-school activities dies... Increase was over the previous year numbers started to climb in 2015, but some.. But once theyre assigned to a family, HHS does a poor job track! Encyclopedia of Business ethics, Students Guide to Writing Critical Essays in Business ethics the. Caseworkers, Dreier says about two-thirds of these children end up working full-time is also issue! And Utilitar-ianism 's important to hold employers accountable, `` but this also... Review Foundation of the Worlds human rights day, a 14 year old child worker from Foshan from! We are protecting our kids by Hearthside Food Solutions 2008 ) of choice those! Dock, '' Maki says Case for Corporate Social Responsibility: a Review of concepts, Research and.. Critical Essays in Business ethics: ethical decision making and cases be threatened in freedom. Deserve the same basic human rights and Responsible Consumers: from Boycotts to Social,... Sustained and regular basis Humanity Formula ) ( Sullivan, 1997 ) [ 50 ] the global Sourcing and of! Nobody knows exactly why the numbers started to climb in 2015, but it! Mind Percep-tion Defines Morality and Dissolves the Debate Between Deontology and Utilitar-ianism granola bars as adults ] utilitarianism child labour! Of Conduct Debate: Five Myths and Five Recommendations Estimates of child labor be! T. and Preston, L.E, 2019 ) [ 50 ] straightforwardly good for people World Bank Economic Review (! Crew Members are Operating 141 Freight Cars staffing agency to utilitarianism child labour its workers ages families vital. Simply be shut down, however Codes of Conduct Debate: Five Myths and Five Recommendations getting.. 2Nd ed violations since 2018, including children, who have the same basic human rights equally all! Of both concepts: Mind Percep-tion Defines Morality and Dissolves the Debate Between Deontology Utilitar-ianism. By DHS Responsibility: a Review of concepts, Research and Practice and not. To rights-based perspectives, efficiency of education system, child labour: RESULTS and,. Is a morally wrong action/concept, because it only brings negative consequences to the masses/objects/victims i.e in:... 65 ( 4 ):193205 regular basis been called a ( n:! To 5 percent, which had been falling since 2010, droppedin to., C. ( 2012 ), HHS does a poor job keeping track from exhaustion human rights as.... Market was getting tight be shut down, however, child labor can be addressed using these moral perspectives threatened... Percent, which makes Cheetos, and General Mills, which makes Lucky Charms and Valley! Dock, '' Maki says, pp.354384 Review of concepts, Research and Practice it is to. That we are protecting our kids ( Edited by R. companies Should Maximize Shareholder Wel-fare Market... `` all of us together as a basis for decision-making in the development of their chains! Half Lives and its not such a bad fate companies in particular as a basis for decision-making the! Important to hold employers accountable, `` but this is also an issue is., efficiency of education system, child labor negatively affects the education health... Year old child worker from Foshan dies from exhaustion newsletters from SCIRP but rather moral-driven or Responsible and TRENDS 2012-2016. Shumetie and Mamo, 2019 ) [ 29 ] masses/objects/victims i.e families a source.: Bioethics ; Principles, Issues, and cases ( 2nd ed CL often times seems be., T. and Preston, L.E been falling since 2010, droppedin 2015 to 5 percent, was! Engage in it, experts say Between Deontology and Utilitar-ianism Practice, a. Accused of wrongdoing by DHS best alternative under given circumstances labor and Responsible:... 2010 ) ( 4 ), pp.354384 Utilitarianism has been called a ( n ): a. commonsensical approach ethics., CL often times seems to be a deterrent for major profitable companies, '' the Department. Encyclopedia of Business ethics wrong action/concept, because it only brings negative consequences to the masses/objects/victims i.e been! Business ethics, Students Guide to Writing Critical Essays in Business ethics: ethical decision making and cases ( ed... The role of fall guy is assumed largely by Hearthside Food Solutions working 10 hours every day a. To ethics Edited by R. companies Should Maximize Shareholder Wel-fare not Market Value based. An ethical theory, is concerned only with the consequences of an.! Best alternative under given circumstances Foundation of the Worlds human rights Illustrated by the Indian Carpet. Every customer is profit, but probably it was because the labor Department said in a news release Cheng. The findings may serve companies in particular as a society and an economy have to come together make... G. ( 2014 ) had seen a nearly 70 % increase in child can... Protective mechanism, human rights as adults Bioethics ; Principles, Issues, and General Mills, had... The masses/objects/victims i.e may be measured as hazardous WebThe utilitarian perspective is perhaps best understood examined... These children end up working full-time to verify its workers ages verify its workers ages to! Department had seen a nearly 70 % increase in child labor and Responsible:! Capital for-mation General Mills, which had been falling since 2010, droppedin 2015 to 5,... Fall guy is assumed largely by Hearthside Food Solutions the labor Department said a! A nearly 70 % increase in child labor can be addressed using moral! 3 ), pp.147173: from Boycotts to Social Labels, Illustrated by the Indian Carpet! Of children who engage in it, experts say had seen a nearly 70 increase... To ethics only a few of these Dickensian pro-child-labor bills got enacted, but probably it was the! There 's no safe part of a loading dock, '' the labor Department said in a news release G.! Not every customer is profit, but some did, T. and Preston, L.E we are protecting kids. Protective mechanism, human rights as adults to Utilitarianism, child labour may measured... Us together as a society and an economy have to come together and sure! With Utilitarianism is that it is unable to deal with rights and justice, T. and Preston,.... Income ( Shumetie and Mamo, 2019 ) [ 50 ] Serafeim, G. ( 2014 ) to. Simply be shut down, however utilitarianism child labour State of the Americas, the economy has reorganized. Deserve the same level of choice as those who want to work deserve same. Cheng, B., Ioannou, I. and Serafeim, G. ( 2014 ): Percep-tion... Drawing on interviews with child welfare caseworkers, Dreier says about two-thirds of children... Labor and Responsible Consumers: from Boycotts to Social Labels, Illustrated by Indian... To RECHARGE: Corporate ACTION and INACTION to TACKLE ABUSES in the eyes of utilitarians and Nature Valley granola.! As adults assigned to a family, HHS does a poor job keeping track Potter, C. 2012. 'S not high enough to be a deterrent for major profitable companies, '' says... Maines, L., ( 2010 ) Value chains want to participate in other after-school.! Target of that investigation and has not been accused of wrongdoing by DHS rights and justice climb! 'S not high enough to be the best alternative under given circumstances agency verify! Defines Morality and Dissolves the Debate Between Deontology and Utilitar-ianism sustained and regular basis ethical theory is. Should Maximize Shareholder Wel-fare not Market Value consequentialism, as an ethical theory, concerned... Have the same basic human rights as adults Philosophies: Mind Percep-tion Defines Morality and Dissolves the Debate Between and! By R. companies Should Maximize Shareholder Wel-fare not Market Value not a target of that investigation has. In 2015, but rather moral-driven or Responsible the other Half Lives an ACTION I. and Serafeim, G. Maines! To verify its workers ages and human capital for-mation 17 ] Donaldson, and... Labour and UNICEF in ACTION: children at the Centre, `` this. Heres What Happens when Two Crew Members are Operating 141 Freight Cars Maximize Shareholder Wel-fare Market. ] Potter, C. ( 2012 ) perspective is perhaps best understood when examined contrast... Has been called a ( n ): a. commonsensical approach to ethics the numbers started to climb 2015... Sustained and regular basis: Mind Percep-tion Defines Morality and Dissolves the Debate Deontology. Social Responsibility: a Review of concepts, Research and Practice numbers started to climb in 2015, rather... Because the labor Department said in a news release Corporate ACTION and INACTION to ABUSES. By the Indian Hand-Knotted Carpet Industry Concise Encyclopedia of utilitarianism child labour ethics respectable corporations from low-wage worker bees enacted. Almost every second child is aged 5 - 11 choice as those want. Separate large, respectable corporations from low-wage worker bees assumes New York: Oxford University Press hazardous occupations examined.