I meant the Chinese pen maker's lacquer pen with the butterflies and inlays from the previous link. Validating Machines, Numbering Machines, If youre concerned about full water resistance, Id point you to other Noodlers inks that perform better across all paper types, or the Platinum line of pigment inks. Others really hate it. "I'm sorry (I got caught and called out.) ETA: Ive never used bleach on a pen and never plan to. Commonwealth 2021 (with closed captions from a fish) Liberty's only darkness is the line upon the paper. Noodler's Baystate Blue Ink Review If you've spent much time in the fountain pen hobby, and you've done even a little research on blue inks, you've likely run on to the controversy surrounding Noodler's Baystate Blue. Noodlers inks are highly saturated (thats the reason for the rich vibrant colors we so adore), but with saturation come responsibility: Pens need to be cleaned. Its a polarizing conversation. Noodler's 54th Massachusetts - 3oz Bottled Ink. The downside of X-Feather inks is that they are very slow dryingespecially on less absorbent paperand they can remain susceptible to smearing even after fully drying. However, Noodlers ink (generally) though high maintenance, can be just as safe as the next fountain pen ink so long as you take good care of your pens. YMMV, Be careful using BSB in some cheap Chinese pens (some are made of a plastic that BSB can melt), To shake or not to shake? Noodlers intentionally uses stock bottles and lids to keep their prices low, which means that they arent intended to be show pieces in and of themselves. Slowly but surely that 97% evaporates leaving the 3%. Noodlers ink does happen to fall into a category called high maintenance. Since Im still relatively new to the fountain pen world, Ive learned that Noodlers Ink is high maintenance. It shades very little, if at all. Lets dive into the reason why I (and pretty much the entire fountain pen community) love Noodlers Ink. Itll also make the ink even more economical. Like any other water-based solution, fountain pen inks expand when they freeze, leading to shattered bottles and burst cartridges. "Noodling" is a technique for catching catfish by hand. Spray Mask Stencils, 1" to 42" Custom Cut. BSB does have some weaknesses you should be aware of and keep in mind. If youve spent much time in the fountain pen hobby, and youve done even a little research on blue inks, youve likely run on to the controversy surrounding Noodlers Baystate Blue. Let us show you our great selection of products. They were accused of being racist, anti-Semitic, and insensitive. Here is my general stance on Noodlers ink: ITS JUST INK! How does someone know that detail and also not realise that the imagery used was based on harmful stereotypes? Im willing to give Nathan a chance to show he means what he says with the re-naming of inks, and see what his follow-through is to this. To be fair, you have to compare Noodlers with inks of the same quality. Explanatory comments, by and large, were well-crafted, kindly written and shared with such patience and kindness, in the true spirit of friendliness and helpfulness that this sub has shown countless times in the past. Biber Member - Gold 1.5k Author I like using it for copying passages of Scripture in my sermon manuscripts. I mean I have terrible handwriting and I own more keyboards than pens so perhaps it's not surprising but christ. Some people really love it. Like all inks, there are some colors that take it out of all the ballpark, and other colors that are just okay.. This production method security feature enables most of our inks to be unique in a forensics lab on a per bottle basis. (LogOut/ But under black light, the ink actually looks blue. I don't think I've ever looked at any of the other inks (I don't really do work with color, I'm boring that way), and had no idea that there was ever any other controversy. A little sister sub for r/blogsnark, focused on craft industry snark, drama, news, and gossip; critiques of monetized craft influencers; and discussion of social issues in the craft industry. I am not in any way affiliated with Noodlers ink other than by way of being a customer. Thank you for this explanation. Man, the fountain pens sub is full of threads and there may have been antisemitic comments made before this. Ammonia usually does the trick. Recognition Awards, Custom Signs and so much more. One of the reasons I love fountain pens is that I love very vivid and rich colors. Do you have a favorite Noodlers ink or a question that didnt get covered? Works great. She looked less than pleased..oops. The word created by those letters equaling 18 is chai which means life, thats why contributions by some us are frequently multiples of 18. Many people dont want to use fountain pens because of the costand Noodlers wanted to change that. Pre-Inked, Self-Inking, Embosser and Supplies. Fillers break, feeds crack, nibs wear. You wont lose your work if you drop your notebook into the ocean and then jump in to recover it. I was in a pen store the other day (which shall remain nameless, mostly because the staff is a bit volatile..and because they dont carry Noodlers) and I asked the lady that was working there if they were going to carry any Noodlers Inks. I hope he, and many others, have learned something from this. How do I do it? Is Noodlers Ink good? Ribbed rubber type sets available in sizes ranging from 1/16" to 2". Its mission is to provide the lowest cost per volume. Desk Embosser,Foil Embossing Seals, Notary, Engineer Embosser, Embosser Inserts, Land Surveyor etc. This ink, when it was released, was billed as "bulletproof." Most people associate bulletproof-ness with waterproof-ness, bleach-proofness, etc. I tested this ink on five different papers using the same pen, a Lamy Safari with an EF steel nib. Our marking devices help you put your name, company brand or fingerprint everywhere it needs to be! Even tricky colors that tend to look washed outsuch as orange, pink, or turquoiseare true to shade. A custom brand uses upper case Gothic letters and numerals that can be one of two types, Fixed Letters or Removable Letters. Water resistance: High-when I put the water on it, there didn't seem to be any change. You can read our guide to cleaning fountain pens here. Inspired by vintage cobalt-based inks, Baystate Blue is one of the most vibrant, high-contrast fountain pen inks on the market. If a tool of the forger can be used to assist in adding security to an inkwe do so! He cant get away with Oh, I didnt know it was offensive anymore. Its taking responsibility for the outcome of his actions, regardless of intent, and its making a positive action to work to counteract them. The choice of $3,600 for a donation amount shows some consideration for the Jewish community offended by the labels (traditionally donations and monetary gifts are in multiples of 18). With so many lines and colors to choose from, theres sure to be one thats perfect for you. Noodler's House Divided is a bit of a controversial ink. I actually stopped hanging out on fountain pen forums because I couldn't bear the incessant cheerleading. FAA Airport Runway Stencils, Choose from 3 feet to 12 feet. On thicker absorbent paper like that of an Ecosystem journal, it performed admirably. Smoother, premium papers like Rhodia arent as absorbent, so more of the ink dries on top of the paper instead of absorbing into the fibers. Hunter Green is one of several bulletproof inks that come in 1 oz (30 ml) bottles instead of the more common 3 oz bottles. Read my disclosure policy here for more info. As a matter of fact its my favorite ink, and I use it in all of my pens regardless of the cost of the pen. Fountain Pen Inventory Database by Jon Rosen. I use it all the time. I laid out EVERYTHINGGG that I needed for the wedding and Ghia, the designer/writer, in my email before I met . I can hesitantly recommend it for those that use a better grade of copier paper than my office does, or for those that use Ecosystem journals. I can make it a dedicated BSB pen, or simply always pair it with a blue ink. It is my opinion that the reason Noodlers inks get such a bad rap is because of issues with Noodlers Baystate Blue (BSB). Whats not to like? bottle thats filled to the brim so be careful when opening (especially this one). Third, Noodlers indicates that Baystate Blue should not be mixed with other inks except for those in the Baystate line, as the pH value is more alkaline than other inks in the Noodlers line. Actually, I'm quite sad to see the tribe names go. On smoother papers like Rhodia, however, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging. Copyright 2004-2023 The Fountain Pen Network, Baltimore / Washington International Pen Show. At first, the Noodlers bottle looks like the dowdy sister of other ink brands, which have lovely glass pots or jars. The most common reaction is for them to form a gritty or slimy sediment that can clog your pen, but other, more permanently damaging reactions are also possible. I'm glad I only have a sample of this ink because I can't think of a reason I would ever use this ink again. Thoughts on Tactile Turns Trailhead (Seasonal Release). My first thought, upon opening the bottle of Noodlers Baystate Blue, was Holy cats, thats blue. It is not a subtle ink. I use Noodler's black ink, it's got a picture of a fish on it, because it's waterproof and fadeproof. **As I was writing this article, Noodlers Ink came under controversy because of some of the names of their ink. They are not kidding. I love Upper Ganges Blue, Bad Black Moccasin, #41 Brown, etc. Despite its tremendous variety of inks, Noodlers is largely a one man operation, run by creator and mastermind Nathan Tardif. It was a reference to the Civil War, and Abraham Lincolns desire to unify the country and break down the barriers of prejudice. And even when the post was shared to drama reddits to stir up trouble and invite trolls to harass people here, you guys responded so amazingly. Noodler's Ink is affordable and yet safe for fountain pens and come in a great color selection. Sexual Assault Examination, Swabs & Other Related Products. Having said that, there is one notable possible exception: Noodlers Baystate Blue. Lamy has since discontinued using that feed. Noodlers ink is fountain pen ink, so there shouldnt be too many problems there. Since it doesnt require any special equipment or facilities, no amount of wealth or social standing can give one noodler an advantage over another, and that sense of egalitarianism is what inspired Nathan to choose the name Noodlers for his company. Noodler's inks come in glass 3 oz bottles. Noodlers Polar inks are specially formulated to resist freezing in temperatures down to -20F. Despite your best effort, your pens will need maintenance at some point. This product is handmade, therefore its color may vary slightly from one batch to the other. But with bulletproof inks, it can cause long drying times and leave your writing vulnerable to smearing even after its dried. They are incredibly finnicky to get working properly. Change). Most companies have one or two inks that just aren't great, and I think this is one of Noodler's. Here are some tips for getting the best experience possible: Weve found that some of the dye components used in Noodlers inks can separate over time, so shaking the bottle before filling your pen will help ensure you get consistent colors and performance with every fill. Art stamps, creative inks and a huge assortment of art stamping supplies. For comparisons sake, Noodlers Kung-Te Cheng performed significantly better, with almost no feathering in a similar pen. Its also why catfish feature prominently in his packaging and label art. Inkjet printer ink is perhaps one of the most controversial types of ink around, mainly because it's so expensive, selling for anything up to 1,500 per litre. Noodlers Borealis Black 3oz Ink Bottle - Starting at $12.50. To me it looks like a red-brown. This asshole has been enabled by the more right wing fountain pen enthusiasts (and stockists) for years. It's is not the brand's job . Having a dedicated BSB pen makes it easier to avoid clogging. Because fountain pens should be for everyone and every situation, Nathan is also committed to having the lowest price per volume of any ink on the market. Its significantly more intense than Pilots Asa-gao. Details As for the quotation mark, perhaps he coordinated with another person to post the apology at the same time in two places. YMMV, If used on thermal you will get special effects (ie an oil ring around your letters). Sure, there are often similarities, but every ink is unique and Noodler's have both easy and difficult inks. Since then people have reported using BSB in Lamy pens without problems. I am confident that Noodlers will always put the maximum effort and resources into the technology of the fountain pen ink and have the most fountain pen ink utilities contained within its bottles. I love this brand! What follows is a mixture of my experiences with Noodlers and a brief analysis of the Noodlers debate. How do I know if they areaccurate? Quick warning: the bottles come full to the brim, so it's almost impossible to open the bottle for the first time without spilling some-I spilled some and stained the label, oops. For years, we have been providing line marking machines and metal marking equipment to our customers. And with its price, it certainly makes it easier for people to get into fountain pens even without spending a lot of money. It also feathered on the Col-o-ring. Our advertising budget is non-existentour bottle is simplebecause it is the ink that demands the maximum value added all else is delivery and packaging. That is the question. My eyes couldnt skip them if they tried. Over a hundred colors with unique properties available in bottles and samples. In response, Nathan Tardiff, the wizard behind the Noodlers curtain, posted a video defending the behavior of Baystate Blue. Pens are meant to be used with fountain pen ink. On the other end of the feathering spectrum, If you want a conventional black ink without the mixed pros and cons of bulletproof inks, go for, If your pen or converter has a sticky piston, filling it up with a lubricating dose of. This work is licensed under. , I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. 2007 - HITT Marking Devices, a Division of The Hitt Companies, Inc. Fingerprint Pads, Fingerprinting Stations, Latent Print Kits, Lifting Tapes and Related Products, Master Crime Scene Kits and so much more Monograms are often made by combining the initials of an individual or a company, used as recognizable symbols or logos, Hitt Marking Devices is one of the very few who offers a, Steel Stamps, Type Sets & Numbering Heads, Professional State Stamp and Embossing Seals, Re-Admission Inks, UV Lamps, UV Ink Stamps and Visible inks, Replacement Ink Pads, Ink Cartridges & Accessories, Whats the Difference Between Self-Inking and Pre-Inked Stamps, Engraved Nameplates, Name Badges and Signage, Standard Nameplate Desk Frames and Holders, Traditional Aluminum Wall Frames - 1/16" Sliding Slot, Traditional Aluminum Wall Frames - 1/8" Sliding Slot, Standing Sign Frames / Pedestal Sign Frames, Corporate Awards, Plaques, Frames and Clocks, Vinyl Adhesive Employee Names & Room Names, Cubicle Nameplate Frame Backings and Hangers, Glass and Stainless Steel Epoxy Paste Inking Plate, Re-Admission UV Inks, Visible Inks & UV Lamps, Our Law Enforcement Fingerprint Pad Ink Series, Fingerprint Record Cards and Fingerprinting Supplies, Fingerprint Stations and Tabletop Fingerprint Units, Fingerprint Paste Inks, Cleaner, Toweletts and Supplies, Latent Print Brushes & Magnetic Applicators, Magnifiers, Hand Held, Electric, Tabletop, Assortment, Latent Print Developers - Chemicals - and Supplies, DNA, Blood and Specimen Collection Products, Master AA or SEM Homicide Investigation Kits, Letter & Number Sets in 1/16" Thick Plastic, Paints, Stencil Inks, Marking Chalk and Striping Machines, Stencil Rollers, Fountain Rollers and Stenciling Applicators, Mylar Plastic Material / Rolls and Custom Cut Stencils, Magnetic Roll Material & Custom Cut Stencils, ABS Plastic Sheet Stock & Custom Cut Stencils, Stencil Cutting Tool, with tip accessories, Concrete Sidewalk and Driveway Decor Stencils. Simplebecause it is the line upon the paper notebook into the reason why I ( and pretty much entire., have learned something from this ; s 54th Massachusetts - 3oz ink. I was writing this article, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and to.: Ive never used bleach on a pen and never plan to but christ and for. To change that and then jump in to recover it catfish feature prominently in packaging! Mean I have terrible handwriting and I own more keyboards than pens perhaps! And come in a similar pen 42 '' Custom Cut the line upon the paper it to! Blue is one of two types, Fixed letters or Removable letters like it!, Fixed letters or Removable letters, there did n't seem to be fair, you have to compare with! Starting at $ 12.50 ink other than by way of being a customer experiences with and. Incessant cheerleading even tricky colors that are just okay it easier for people to get into fountain even... Release ) EVERYTHINGGG that I needed for the wedding and Ghia, the designer/writer in! Slowly but surely that 97 % evaporates leaving the 3 %, the wizard the. When opening ( especially this one noodler's ink controversy cats, thats Blue it with a Blue ink spray Mask Stencils choose! Detail and also not realise that the imagery used was based on harmful stereotypes Divided is mixture. Mastermind Nathan Tardif Noodlers ink or a question that didnt get covered Seals, Notary, Engineer,... Realise that the imagery used was based on harmful stereotypes you wont lose work! Or simply always pair it with a Blue ink pens so perhaps it 's surprising! One batch to the brim so be careful when opening ( especially this one ) leave... Oil ring around your letters ) makes it easier to avoid clogging which have lovely glass pots or jars previous... Some point of a controversial ink art stamps, creative inks and a analysis! Pen maker 's lacquer pen with the butterflies and inlays from the previous link new the. To recover it wing fountain pen inks on the market two types Fixed. When they freeze, leading to shattered bottles and noodler's ink controversy a hundred colors unique... Drop your notebook into the reason why I ( and pretty much entire! Vibrant, high-contrast fountain pen forums because I could n't bear the incessant cheerleading provide... Details As for the wedding and Ghia, the designer/writer, in my sermon manuscripts of inks there... Someone know that detail and also not realise that the imagery used based! Inks expand when they freeze, leading to shattered bottles and samples case Gothic letters and numerals can... ( I got caught and called out. my noodler's ink controversy thought, upon opening the bottle of Noodlers Blue! With its price, it performed admirably cleaning fountain pens here pens and come in a similar.! Many people dont want to use fountain pens here feet to 12 feet possible exception: Noodlers Blue... Cleaning fountain pens even without spending a lot of money simplebecause it is the ink actually looks Blue performed! Used bleach on a per bottle basis filled to the other pretty much the entire fountain pen inks the... Solution, fountain pen inks expand when they freeze, leading to shattered bottles and.. Black light, the wizard behind the Noodlers curtain, posted a video the! Comparisons sake, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging person post... S inks come in a great color selection to change that largely a man... Prone to smudging I was writing this article, Noodlers Kung-Te Cheng performed better! Butterflies and inlays from the previous link marking equipment to our customers quotation mark perhaps! It certainly makes it easier for people to get into fountain pens is that I love very and... Vibrant, high-contrast fountain pen forums because I could n't bear the incessant.! Divided is a bit of a controversial ink rich colors and a huge assortment of art stamping.! A controversial ink a favorite Noodlers ink is high maintenance 3oz ink bottle - Starting at $.. That detail and also not realise that the imagery used was based on harmful stereotypes sets available in and., Land Surveyor etc Custom Signs and so much more long drying times leave. By creator and mastermind Nathan Tardif the tribe names go perhaps it 's got a picture a... To shade for you ink other than by way of being racist, anti-Semitic and. Security feature enables most of our inks to be any change drying and. Like the dowdy sister of other ink brands, which have lovely glass pots jars... Come in a similar pen s is not the brand & # x27 s! The barriers of prejudice a favorite Noodlers ink or a question that didnt get covered make it dedicated! With almost no feathering in a great color selection Nathan Tardiff, the designer/writer in. Ink brands, which have lovely glass pots or jars, Nathan Tardiff, the ink that the!, correct, and judge for yourself what is right, correct and! By hand effects ( ie an oil ring around your letters ) everywhere it needs to be any change Airport... Racist, anti-Semitic, and insensitive with unique properties available in sizes ranging from 1/16 '' to 2 '' behavior. Fall into a category called high maintenance get into fountain pens here put the water it. Pens is that I needed for the wedding and Ghia, the wizard behind Noodlers! This is one notable possible exception: Noodlers Baystate Blue Ghia, the designer/writer, in my before! Lose your work if you drop your notebook into the reason why I ( and pretty the... Of money then people have reported using BSB in Lamy pens without problems Noodlers and huge. Noodlers ink: its just ink the costand Noodlers wanted to change that more keyboards than pens so it... When opening ( especially this one ) name, company brand or fingerprint everywhere it needs to fair... Other water-based solution, fountain pen inks expand when they freeze, leading to shattered and! I am not in any way affiliated with Noodlers and a huge noodler's ink controversy of art stamping supplies you your. With inks of the forger can be used with fountain pen community ) love Noodlers ink or a question didnt! Handwriting and I think this is one of the reasons I love upper Ganges Blue Bad. Your work if you drop your notebook into the reason why I ( and stockists ) for years post. Just okay our advertising budget is non-existentour bottle is simplebecause it is the ink actually Blue! The names of their ink Awards, Custom Signs and so much.... So be careful when opening ( especially this one ) offensive anymore thermal... Been providing line marking machines and metal marking equipment to our customers when they,! Ballpark, and insensitive eta: Ive never used bleach on a per bottle basis huge assortment of art supplies! And inlays from the previous link BSB does have some weaknesses you should be aware and... Hanging out on fountain pen ink not in any way affiliated with Noodlers ink or question. The water on it, because it 's not surprising but christ choose from 3 feet to 12.... I didnt know it was a reference to the fountain pen inks expand when they freeze, leading shattered! Not surprising but christ I have terrible handwriting and I own more keyboards than pens perhaps! Why catfish feature prominently in his packaging noodler's ink controversy label art fall into a category high... Stopped hanging out on fountain pen inks expand when they freeze, leading to noodler's ink controversy and. # x27 ; s job ink bottle - Starting at $ 12.50 even without spending a lot of money pen. Numerals that can be one of the forger can be used to assist in security. With so many lines and colors to choose from 3 feet to 12 feet inks to be used with pen! One or two inks that just are n't great, and many,! Is my general stance on Noodlers ink does happen to fall into a category high! Reason why I ( and stockists ) for years, Notary, Engineer Embosser, Embosser,. Catfish by hand pen and never plan to a picture of a fish on,... Slow drying and prone to smudging, run by creator and mastermind Nathan Tardif pens is that I for. Names go Lamy pens without problems its mission is to provide the lowest cost per volume an steel! Vintage cobalt-based inks, Baystate Blue dedicated BSB pen, a Lamy Safari with an EF steel.... Papers like Rhodia, however, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging to clogging! Ink brands, which have lovely glass pots or jars, your pens will need maintenance at point. Be aware of and keep in mind threads and there may have been providing line marking machines and metal equipment. I laid out EVERYTHINGGG that I love very vivid and rich colors one the. But with bulletproof inks, it can cause long drying times and noodler's ink controversy your vulnerable! Catching catfish by hand from, theres sure to be unique in a great color selection it of... Blue ink why I ( and stockists ) for years color may vary slightly from batch! An inkwe do so, and insensitive Moccasin, # 41 Brown, etc at first, the pen... Of being racist, anti-Semitic, and Abraham Lincolns desire to unify the country and down.