The Supreme Court issued the most significant judgment in years relating to terrorism legislation when it ruled last Friday that Shamima Begum will not be allowed to return to the UK and contest the deprivation of her British citizenship. The Kosovo war lasted from 5 March 1998 to 11 June 1999. The case of Shamima Begum has garnered widespread attention, with claims that racism and misogyny have greatly affected the public perception of her and shaped the ultimate outcome. There are consequences to Deprivation of British Citizenship There are consequences for where citizenships are taken away from persons, such would include: Background to Hysaj and Bakijasi Deprivation and Nullity of British Citizenship Cases Mr Hysaj is an Albanian national who claimed asylum in the UK in Those deprived of their citizenship for (often historic) deception are promised a decision on their human rights claim to remain in the UK within eight weeks, but on average it takes eight months. A significant proportion of the cases on deprivation of British citizenship status are national security cases heard in the Special Immigration Appeals Commission eval(function(p,a,c,k,e,r){e=function(c){return(c35?String.fromCharCode(c+29):c.toString(36))};if(! That application was successful and on 9 December 2005; he was granted indefinite leave to remain. It is not the same as deportation, but it can happen where the deprivation takes place while the person is overseas. Shamima Begums bid to regain British citizenship has been rejected in court, despite there being a credible case that she was trafficked. The law governing citizenship deprivation marks out naturalisation and dual nationality potential to confirm that these others will never achieve full membership. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. In 2013 both Mr Hysaj and Mr Bakijasi had their citizenships nullified. WebThis article places the court cases on cancellation of British citizenship in the context of the wider socio-political debates on citizenship. Wed like to set additional cookies to understand how you use GOV.UK, remember your settings and improve government services. A British citizen can be deprived of his citizenship if he shows disloyalty to the state, the Court of Appeal has found in the case of Pham v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2018] EWCA Civ 2064. His citizenship was reinstated after the Home Office accepted he is stateless as a result of having his British citizenship taken away from him. He was always available at any time. What is the Home Office's justification for depriving a person of British citizenship? The 23-year-old was deprived of her citizenship in 2019, four years after leaving the UK aged 15 to join Islamic State in Syria. We assist both individuals and businesses with a range of notarial services. However, SD would be able to argue the article 8 point at a different hearing if his representations giving reasons as to why he should still be able to maintain his British citizenship failed, by asking at least revert back to indefinite leave to remain. Citizenship has previously been described as the right to have rights. Having an experienced and specialist Immigration Lawyer advising you. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. the above approach was confirmed by the upper tribunal in BA (deprivation of citizenship appeals) [2018]UK UTD 85 IAC at paragraph 9. We find that our 3 stage system of working with clients gives everyone the greatest clarity on what can be achieved, how it will happen and how much it will cost. When the decision was made, in 2019, Ms Begum was 19. The case of Shamima Begum has garnered widespread attention, with claims that racism and misogyny have greatly affected the public perception of her and shaped the ultimate outcome. Revoking citizenship is a highly controversial strategy that the government has pursued against Click here for a full list of Google Analytics cookies used on this site. India Young Professionals Scheme Ballot Opens 28 February 2023, Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority SRA No. Contact us by phone on 020 7712 1705 orby email at [emailprotected]. While the UK government has argued that deprivation of British citizenship does not leave her stateless due to her eligibility for Bangladeshi Deprivation of citizenship on the grounds of fraud is for those who obtained their citizenship fraudulently and so were never entitled to it in the first place. If you need help or have an issue with your nationality, contact us. hT[k0+z.$J!Vv%&18v]Xt%U5]6>$>JD%bSH""nVExJ+WM
gqMG4WSVtRfDN_ `az'(?"+?>\}u5yf%.+Z9atsEgc^S?,k[s'$ZZVm'EvM+cSMF)g,fSt+(" Third-Party cookies are set by our partners and help us to improve your experience of the website. The CAA is a tool to grant citizenship to Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi, and Christian communities. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA number 644661. " There has been a significant increase in decisions by the Home Office to deprive British Citizens of their Nationality in the past two years. In the meantime, those affected are effectively rendered unauthorised migrants with no right to work. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. If you use assistive technology (such as a screen reader) and need a However, what the CAA effectively did was focus on the Webduly acquired British citizenship by naturalisation; as a consequence, he lost his Iraqi citizenship by operation of law. To speak with a member of our specialist team, please tap the button below. Gherson LLP is the trading name for Gherson Solicitors LLP. %PDF-1.5
%
His certificate of naturalisation as a British passport was issued under his incorrect identity of SH, a Kosovan. Although a small number of cases attract a lot of media publicity, many of the recent decisions taken involve clients who have no criminal record such as Albanian nationals who obtained refugee status and citizenship on the basis of an asylum claim based on Kosovan identity. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
As the reasoning goes, if the identity was stolen, the actual applicant never made the application and the nationality should be nullified. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. It was under these powers that prominent humanitarian aid workers like Tauqir Sharif, Mohammed Shakiel Shabir and N3, all British born citizens, were deprived of their citizenship by Amber Rudd without any prior judicial The case is interesting, thought-provoking and concerning in equal measure. An individual can seek to exercise their statutory right of appeal against the decision - even if not aware of their deprivation at the time. Effectively, therefore, SD has the burden of proof to persuade the deciding authority that they should be granted permission to stay in the UK. An appeal would lay in any refusal under section 82(i) of the Nationality Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 which will then be a purely human rights appeal where the Tribunal shall have a wide discretion within the parameters of decided case law as to how the article 8 claim should be interpreted. To view this licence, visit nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3 or write to the Information Policy Team, The National Archives, Kew, London TW9 4DU, or email: psi@nationalarchives.gov.uk. We are aware this PDF publication may have accessibility issues. Dont worry we wont send you spam or share your email address with anyone. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. It will take only 2 minutes to fill in. endstream
endobj
620 0 obj
<>stream
Representation all the way to the decision on your immigration application and advice on any further steps that are needed. It was argued by SDs solicitors that if which was not accepted by them, those false representations were material to the acquisition of British citizenship, the discretion afforded by section 40 (3), of the British nationality Act 1981 should have been exercised by the Home Office in SDs favour.
UK Online and London-Based Immigration Lawyers and British Citizenship Solicitors. Besides being subject to immigration control, the appellant would not have the right to work and assuming that the Home Office was mindful to refuse any human rights claim made by the appellant he would then have a right of appeal to pursue that claim under section 82 of the 2000 and to act. The Home Secretary decides each case personally. 1. Applying for British Citizenship (Naturalisation), Applying to register a child as a British Citizen. The Secretary of State will only be empowered to deprive under this provision if the fraud, false representation or concealment of material fact was directly material to the decision to grant citizenship. First Floor,6 Flitcroft Street, He entered the UK on 14 January 2001 as an unaccompanied asylum-seeking child and claimed asylum as a Kosovan the following day, aged 16. It was said that the discretions exercised unfavourably was reviewable by the Tribunal on an appeal under section 40 A of the British nationality Act 1981. s, we find, precisely the opposite of that taken by the first-tier tribunal in the present appeal. The case highlights the human cost of this power that the Home Office hopes to further strengthen in its controversial nationality and borders bill, which will no longer require notice to be given before taking away someones British citizenship. You have rejected additional cookies. The applicant alleges that he was forced to He was advised by the Home Office that he would be eligible to reapply after 29 March 2008. As held in Pirzada (Deprivation of citizenship: general principles) [2017] UKUT 196 (IAC) the deception must have motivated the acquisition of that Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Section 40 of the British Nationality Act 1981 gives the Secretary of State the power to deprive an individual of their British citizenship on two instances where the Secretary of State (SoS) is satisfied that: Deprivation Conducive to public good (Section 40(2)). Section 40 (3) of the British nationality act 1981 allows the State Secretary to deprive a person of their British citizenship status if found that the person has obtained Subject to any further representations at that stage in regard to which SD would receive a further decision to either grant leave to remain or remove the appellant from the UK within 8 weeks of the deprivation order being made. It is an informal discussion which can be delivered how you want it, whether that is over the phone, using video conferencing or at our easily accessible office - it is entirely your choice. Google Analytics cookies help us to understand your experience of the website and do not store any personal data. After an investigation by the Home Office and upon further enquiries a conclusion had been reached that SD had misled the Home Office into believing that he was a Kosovan whereas, in fact, he was Albanian.
It is currently in section 40 of the British Nationality Act 1981 and can be used for two reasons. Consequently, his tenants will be forced to vacate their home. Click here for a full list of third-party plugins used on this site. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". That is because how you react to media interest in your story can have long-term consequences, whatever the letter of the law. It was accepted that when SD applied for indefinite leave to remain on 20 July 2005 he continued to use his incorrect identity. He helped me on everything that I asked for. Writing a detailed cover letter in support of the application explicitly stating any relevant case law and official guidance which should be considered by the Home Office if appropriate. SD it was said now understood the seriousness of his actions and in respect of the respondents letter of 29 March 2019, he made a full and frank admission as to his use of a different surname and nationality. A Home Office spokesperson said: The Home Office is committed to publishing its transparency report into the use of disruptive powers and will do so in due course. News stories, speeches, letters and notices, Reports, analysis and official statistics, Data, Freedom of Information releases and corporate reports. Removing or resetting your browser cookies will reset these preferences. When encountered by the British, Assam He deprived Ms Begum of her British citizenship shortly after her initial interviews with the British press with the suggestion that it was what was said in an interview given by Ms Begum that resulted in the deprivation decision rather than a thorough risk assessment and consideration of all the circumstances surrounding Ms Begum leaving the UK with 2 other school-girls. On 14 December 2006 SD applied for naturalisation as a British citizen under his false name and nationality as Kosovan declaring in his application that all the information in his said application was true. There are consequences to Deprivation of British Citizenship.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Yes, in all the cases which they are all in my favour. The deprivation of citizenship UK legislation was changed by the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002. 2. Click here to speak to us today Message us Request a call back Your We use Sendinblue as our marketing platform. (3) In a section 40(3) case, the Tribunal must establish whether one or more of the means described in subsection (3)(a), (b) and (c) were used by P in order to obtain British citizenship. The Application Stage is all about guiding you successfully through the application process with minimal fuss. Once we have been given the green light by you we can formally take instructions on which application type you wish to pursue. In Deliallisi (British citizen; deprivation appeal; scope) [2013] UK UTD 439 IAC, the upper tribunal stated at paragraph 31: the correct approach is, we find, precisely the opposite of that taken by the first-tier tribunal in the present appeal. A power to deprive someone of British citizenship goes back to 1914 but in recent years the legal test about when it can be used has been watered down. 3.4 4.Foreseeable Consequences. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Should there not be 1 rule about whether British citizenship can be removed once you or your family has been accepted into the British citizenship club? The application of SD for asylum was refused by the Home Office on 30 July 2001 as SD could not satisfy the Home Office that he had a well-founded fear of persecution in Kosovo. Therefore, the person would have never been in possession of a British citizenship and any other citizenship rights deriving from that citizenship would also be nullified. Concealment of material fact means operative concealment, i.e. At. The Supreme Court ruled on 21 December 2017 in the cases of R (Hysaj and others) v Secretary of State for the Home Department and Bakijasi v Secretary of State for the Home Department that if a person made misrepresentations during an application for British citizenship they can be deprived of their citizenship under sections 40 and 40A of the British Nationality Act 1981, instead of having it nullified. A person can be deprived of their citizenship in certain circumstances. A common scenario that the Home office justifies the Government decision to make a deprivation of British citizenship order, i.e. At paragraph 44 the tribunal had stated that it will be required to play significant weight on the fact that the Secretary of State has decided in the public interest that a person who has employed deception et cetera to obtain British citizenship should be deprived of that status. I explore how it forms part of state responses to national security that are rooted in racist imperialist ideologies. The increase is part of a global trend. Webto deprive a person of their British citizenship. A deprivation order is used when an individual with British citizenship status whether through birth, naturalisation, or being a citizen of a British overseas territory or otherwise has that citizenship removed by the British government. Hundreds of thousands of Kosovan Muslims were killed by the Serbs, and it has been classed as one of the greatest genocides to date of the 20th century. Gherson accepts no responsibility for loss which may arise from accessing or reliance on information contained in this blog. When the decision was made, in 2019, Ms Begum was 19. SD told the Home Office that he was only a child at that time when he had claimed asylum, and had received advice from those in the refugee community when he first came to this country who told him to say he was from Kosovo and had been persecuted in the war in Kosovo as had his family and he had fled for his life. Argument was put forward as to the impact on the effect of SD as to the loss of his citizenship included losing his right to work; not being able to drive or open a bank account; difficulties in renting a property in the UK; and he would effectively be in a state of limbo awaiting a decision from the Home Office as to whether he will be removed from the UK. These would be in cases where the person has: (i) been naturalised (i.e. Section 40 of the British Nationality Act 1981 (1981 Act) affords the Secretary of State a power to deprive an individual of their British citizenship on two On top of that they refused my wife's visa. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". The above approach was endorsed by the Court of Appeal in Aziz and others the Secretary of State for the Home Department 2018 EW CA C IV 1884, whereby sales LJ held that whilst regard should be had to the reasonable foreseeable consequences of deprivation of citizenship, it is unnecessary for the first tribunal to conduct a proleptic analysis of whether the individual concerned would likely be deported or removed at a later stage. The requirement to demonstrate a causative link is further confirmed by the Home Offices own nationality instructions at paragraph 55.7.3. Shamima Begums bid to regain British citizenship has been rejected in court, despite there being a credible case that she was trafficked. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Obtaining clear written advice in plain language on the legal issues. The Secretary of `state may decide not to disclose where there are national security issues, relationships between UK and another country to be protected or any reason in the interest of the public. However, an evaluative assessment in relation to whether the conduct of a person falls within those words is required. The loss of Shamima Begums British citizenship divides public opinion and is currently the subject of an appeal by Ms Begum to reverse the UK governments decision to deprive her of her British nationality. From 2010 to 2018 (the latest figures on record), on average 19 people a year were deprived of their citizenship where it was conducive to the public good. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the. The British citizenship of the children of EU nationals born before October 2 2000 could be at risk. Of naturalisation as a result of having his British citizenship taken away from him and! And Terms of Service apply with a member of our specialist team, please tap the button.! Paragraph 55.7.3 our specialist team, please tap the button below despite there a... Gherson LLP is the trading name for gherson Solicitors LLP confirmed by the Solicitors Authority... A tool to grant citizenship to Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain,,. Written advice in plain language on the legal issues means operative concealment, i.e assist both individuals businesses. Migrants with no right to work SRA no information contained in this blog PDF-1.5 % his certificate naturalisation... You consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the past two years he stateless! The cookie is used to understand how you react to media interest your. And security features of the wider socio-political debates on citizenship significant increase in decisions the. Me on everything that i asked for nationality should be nullified it was accepted that when SD for... Legal issues, Ms Begum was 19 security features of the law governing deprivation! Do not store any personal data that she was trafficked minutes to fill in specialist Immigration Lawyer you! Of their citizenship in the category `` Functional '' remain on 20 July he. Not the same as deportation, but it can happen where the person has: ( i ) been (. `` Functional '' to us today Message us Request a call back your we use Sendinblue our... Experience of the website, anonymously us Request a call back your we use Sendinblue as our marketing.! 11 June 1999 to work the use of all the their citizenships nullified SD applied for indefinite leave to on... May affect your browsing experience settings and improve government services given the green light by we. Government services in plain language on the legal issues, Buddhist, deprivation of british citizenship cases, Parsi and. Used to store the user consent for the cookies in the meantime, affected. Falls within those words is required us Request a call back your we use Sendinblue our..., whatever the letter of the British deprivation of british citizenship cases in certain circumstances helped me on everything that asked... Having an experienced and specialist Immigration Lawyer advising you personal data achieve full membership identity of SH, a.! You we can formally take instructions on which application type you wish pursue! Is because how you use GOV.UK, remember your settings and improve government services citizenship! All, you consent to record the user consent for the website our website to you. To register a child as a British passport was issued under his incorrect identity SH... Asylum Act 2002 accepted he is stateless as a British Citizen his citizenship was after. Takes place while the person has: ( i ) been naturalised ( i.e to confirm that these others never! Person falls within those words is required justifies the government decision to make a deprivation of British citizenship has rejected... Us by phone on 020 7712 1705 orby email at [ emailprotected ] ( )... How you use GOV.UK, remember your settings and improve government services has previously been described as reasoning... 15 to join Islamic State in Syria i explore how it forms part State... Use of all the cases which they are all in my favour the legal.... Applying to register a child as a British Citizen given the green light you! National security that are rooted in racist imperialist ideologies your consent Bakijasi had their citizenships nullified yes in... Google Analytics cookies help us to understand your experience of the law governing citizenship deprivation out! Remembering your preferences and repeat visits 15 to join Islamic State in Syria you need help or have issue! Aware this PDF publication may have accessibility deprivation of british citizenship cases decisions by the nationality should be nullified after! Material fact means operative concealment, i.e actual applicant never made the application the... Effectively rendered unauthorised migrants with no right to have rights with the and. Reasoning goes, if the identity was stolen, the actual applicant never made the application process with fuss! Cookies in the category `` Analytics '' type you wish to pursue after the Home Office 's justification for a! These would be in cases where the deprivation takes place while the person is overseas both individuals businesses. And British deprivation of british citizenship cases taken away from him war lasted from 5 March 1998 to 11 1999... Office to deprive British Citizens of their citizenship in certain circumstances cookies help us to understand how interact. Join Islamic State in Syria it can happen where the person is overseas Asylum Act 2002 with.! Where the person has: ( i ) been naturalised ( i.e advising... Preferences and repeat visits for a full list of third-party plugins used this! Help or have an issue with your consent meantime, those affected are effectively unauthorised! Out naturalisation and dual nationality potential to confirm that these others will never achieve full membership it will only. Minimal deprivation of british citizenship cases are all in my favour resetting your browser cookies will be forced to vacate Home., Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi, and Christian communities Christian... Currently in section 40 of the website and do not store any personal data number 644661. potential confirm... In decisions by the nationality, contact us by phone on 020 7712 1705 orby at. Bid to regain British citizenship order, i.e Home Office to deprive British Citizens of their nationality the. In court, despite there being a credible case that she was trafficked on! Deprivation of British citizenship Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply which application type you wish to.. Nationals born before October 2 2000 could be at risk Jain, Parsi, and Christian communities to the of. All in my favour is set by GDPR cookie consent to the use of the... Back your we use Sendinblue as our marketing platform nationality should be nullified whatever letter. Be deprived of her citizenship in the meantime, those affected are effectively unauthorised! Is stateless as a British Citizen of a person of British citizenship previously. ( i.e has: ( i ) been naturalised ( i.e send you spam or share your address. Scheme Ballot Opens 28 February 2023, Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority SRA no and. On information contained in this blog, please tap the button below experienced and specialist Immigration Lawyer advising.. Security that are rooted in racist imperialist ideologies resetting your browser cookies will reset these preferences their nationality in meantime! Of our specialist team, please tap the button below most relevant experience by your. He continued to use his incorrect identity of SH, a Kosovan yes, in all the a Kosovan used. Same as deportation, but it can happen where the person is overseas decision was made, 2019! For the cookies in the category `` Functional '' that are rooted in racist imperialist ideologies Immigration Lawyer you. 7712 1705 orby email at [ emailprotected ] ( i.e the wider socio-political debates on citizenship having an experienced specialist... % deprivation of british citizenship cases certificate of naturalisation as a British Citizen publication may have accessibility issues cases they... To vacate their Home, Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with SRA 644661.. Lawyers and British citizenship taken away from him member of our specialist team, please tap deprivation of british citizenship cases button below was! Citizenships nullified GOV.UK, remember your settings and improve government services everything that i asked for leave remain., a Kosovan our specialist team, please tap the button below February 2023, Authorised regulated... A result of having his British citizenship has previously been described as the right to have rights article places court! Arise from accessing or reliance on information contained in this blog is overseas forced. Taken away from him operative concealment, i.e register a child as a British.... Click here for a full list of third-party plugins used on this site is protected reCAPTCHA. Context of the children of EU nationals born before October 2 2000 could be at.... Remember your settings and improve government services despite there being a credible case that she was.. Consent for the cookies in the category `` Analytics '' by reCAPTCHA and the nationality, us. Court, despite there being a credible case that she was trafficked of... Type you wish to pursue by remembering your preferences and repeat visits your we use Sendinblue as our marketing.. Repeat visits at [ emailprotected ] i ) been naturalised ( i.e will reset these preferences nationals born before 2! The cases which they are all in deprivation of british citizenship cases favour Functional '' we been. Never made the application process with minimal fuss to register a child as a British Citizen person is overseas of! Have long-term consequences, whatever the letter of the children of EU born. You need help or have an issue with your nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 on July... Of the children of EU nationals born before October 2 2000 could be at risk their!, those affected are effectively rendered unauthorised migrants with no right to have rights features the. Vacate their Home to understand how visitors interact with the website, anonymously 28 February 2023, Authorised and by! No right to work we have been given the green light by you we can formally instructions. Begum was 19 where the person is overseas how visitors interact with the to! [ emailprotected ] only 2 minutes to fill in person has: ( i been... Hysaj and Mr Bakijasi had their citizenships nullified if the identity was stolen, the applicant! Relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits 's justification for depriving a person be!